top of page

MENTAL HEALTH AND CRIMINAL SENTENCING IN QUEENSLAND | Navigating the Complexities



MENTAL HEALTH AND CRIMINAL SENTENCING IN QUEENSLAND | Navigating the Complexities

In Queensland, Section 26 of the Criminal Code 1899 presumes that every person is of sound mind unless evidence suggests otherwise.


When criminal acts occur due to reasons of insanity, the legal framework outlined in Section 27 comes into play. This section defines insanity as a state of mental disease or natural mental infirmity, relieving the individual of criminal responsibility if they lacked the capacity to understand or control their actions.


Legal Implications of Insanity and Delusions


While the law acknowledges the impact of delusions on an individual's state of mind, it doesn't grant complete immunity. Those affected by delusions may still be held criminally responsible, emphasizing that proof of insanity doesn't guarantee freedom from consequences.


Court Proceedings and Insanity


If the defence of insanity is successfully raised, the court may result in a 'qualified acquittal.' This implies that the defendant is acquitted due to unsoundness of mind but may face other controls, such as admission to an authorized mental health service. Section 647 of the Criminal Code further defines the process of acquittal on the grounds of insanity.

Diminished Responsibility in Unlawful Murder Cases


Section 304A introduces the concept of diminished responsibility in cases of unlawful murder.

Individuals in a state of ‘abnormality of mind’ may be guilty of manslaughter rather than murder if their capacity to understand, control their actions, or know the wrongfulness of their conduct is substantially impaired.


Mental Illness and Criminal Offences


The intersection of mental illness and criminal charges is a complex landscape.


The Mental Health Act 2016 defines mental illness and outlines objectives to divert individuals from the criminal justice system if found of unsound mind or unfit for trial.


The Mental Health Court plays a crucial role in determining the appropriate orders for those affected.


Seeking legal advice from an experienced criminal law firm becomes paramount in navigating the complexities of mental health and criminal offenses.


Contact Creevey Horrell Criminal Lawyers


Based in Brisbane, Roma, Toowoomba, and Townsville.

Visit www.chcriminallawyers.com.au/contact-us to contact us today.



bottom of page